Putting booklet together

I put my booklet together in indesign and print on shiny paper. I made the cover slightly thicker than the inside paper to show a difference and so the cover was stronger. I decided to rip the edges of some  booklets to create a deckle style edge and cut some normally. This is so I could decide better which works best. When thinking about binding the booklet I wanted to use a binding method which was best for mass production but also worked well with the small content and page number. I felt the most masculine binding method from the outside of the book was staple bound. This also seemed the most practical. I need to get some feedback on my booklet finding out wether the ripped edges work best.