Saturday, October 17, 2015

YSP Symbol Final Critique

Yesterday I presented my final symbol design to a group of other students and one of my tutors. I made a powerpoint Presentation and talked through my initial ideas, experiments and final outcomes. I got some written and verbal feedback which i will take on board in other projects.
This is my presentation
Some pictures of sculptures I took on the trip.

My initial experiments and what I found worked and didn't work.

Joan Miro's ideas and why I liked what he stood for and how it links to YSP.

Final Symbol and what makes it unique and stand out.


Peers Feedback
  • Range of logos- good to see if ideas would work.
  • Good research on artist and incorporating it into work.
  • Good research into artist and how his beliefs intertwined with the park.
  • Clear about initial ideas and styles
  • Detailed research worked well into the work 
  • Possibly add more development and different possible outcomes and justifications
  • Strong design, possibly look into colour
  • Specific sculpture inspiration
  • Good, clear, simplistic logo
  • Good reasons why you choose the sculpture
  • Symbol is good, could it be used with colour
  • Good variety of symbols and recognition
  • Good research 
  • Type didn't suit your symbol
  • Good that you kept with the theme
  • I like the tribal feel to it
  • Would be nice to see colour within the logo to represent busy family atmosphere that the park has
  • I like the abstract final design, How did you get there? 
  • I like the negative space and how it works on a small and large scale
  • Good use of words such as abstract and simple
  • Good use of negative space
  • Good initial ideas
  • Good research 
  • Very simple but effective
  • I like the negative space
  • Natural line representational of the park
Tutor Feedback
  • Good identification of sculpture forms over nature.
  • Good Combination of nature and sculpture.
  • Would be good to explore a range of approaches.

No comments:

Post a Comment